Nick Smart has responded to the home secretary's announcement of a fast stream to superintendent process as part of the implementation of the recommendations of the Leadership Commission. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood is set to announce the new process at the annual conference of the APCC and NPCC on Wednesday 18th November:
"We have been clear that we are supportive of leadership reform to enhance standards across the Service. Our association provided extensive evidence and feedback to support the work of the commission.
"We have been clear that we are supportive of leadership reform to enhance standards across the Service. Our association provided extensive evidence and feedback to support the work of the commission.
"We welcomed the 27 recommendations made, but stressed the need for consultation and engagement with the workforce to ensure the lived realities of policing inform this work.
"It is extremely disappointing that despite today's announcement, we have no further detail on this proposal, nor have we been consulted with over the way in which a fast stream system to superintendent could work. Our most recent member survey found that 88% of respondents believe the government does not value policing as highly as other public services. The lack of meaningful consultation on significant proposals such as this only serves to reinforce those concerns.
"There is a huge amount of talent already in the police workforce. Dedicated individuals carry out exceptional work every day and it is right that they are supported in their development. Currently, there is no formal definition of what 'talent' in policing is, however, and feedback tells us that selection processes are inconsistently applied and subjective. It is crucial therefore, that there are fair systems in place when promoting people through fast track streams, so that there is equity of opportunity for all.
"Direct Entry to superintendent level was not implemented by the majority of forces during the last introduction. If the service will be encouraging external candidates into these roles, who do not have the operational credibility of officers with experience from constable rank upwards, it must be clear what would be different, to ensure that forces have faith in this system.
"We also need to understand how any changes such as these will be funded. As with all reform pledges and announcements to date, there is no detail of how the government will pay for them. Current estimates suggest our budget shortfall will hit £4.3bn by 2030.
"We will continue to support efforts to improve and reform policing, and will now be contacting the Home Office to understand how the representative body for superintendents and chief superintendents will be formally engaged in the development of this workforce change."
